Guide
How to pick fair football teams
Nothing empties a weekly game faster than the same team winning 12–2 every week. Fair teams keep it competitive and keep people coming back. Here are the methods that work, from quickest to most balanced.
Method 1: Two captains pick
The classic. Two players take turns picking until everyone is on a team.
- Good: fast, no tools needed, everyone understands it.
- Bad: the same people get picked last, which isn’t great for newcomers. Captains tend to pick their mates.
- Make it fairer: make the two best players captains, and let the captain who picks second get the next two picks (1-2-2-2…).
Method 2: The organiser picks
One person who knows everyone’s game splits the teams before kick-off and posts them.
- Good: no awkward picking on the pitch, and you can balance properly.
- Bad: relies on one person’s judgement, and they can get the blame for a mismatch.
Method 3: Simple ratings
Give each regular a rough rating, say 1 to 5, and split the players so the totals on each side are close. Start by putting the two highest-rated players on opposite teams, then keep adding the next-best player to whichever team has the lower total.
Tip: keep ratings private and rough. The point is balance, not a league table of who’s best.
Think about positions, not just ability
Two evenly rated teams can still be lopsided if one has both keepers or all the fast players. When you split, check each side has:
- someone happy to go in goal (or agree to rotate);
- at least one player who’ll defend;
- a mix of pace and fitness.
Keep regular duos apart
Players who play together every week build an understanding that’s hard to beat. Splitting up the strongest pairings is one of the easiest ways to even things out.
Fixing a one-sided game
Even good picks go wrong sometimes. If one team is three or four goals up early, swap a player or two at half-time or after the next goal. Agree up front that this is normal so nobody takes it personally.
Bibs and colours
Decide who wears bibs before you get to the pitch and make sure someone is bringing them, along with a ball and a pump. It saves ten minutes of faffing at kick-off.
Where an app helps
In KICKAPP the organiser drags players into two teams on a pitch view, sets the team names and bib colours for the game, and publishes the line-ups so everyone knows their side before they arrive. Swaps are just a drag, and the subs bench is right there if someone drops out.
Let the app do the chasing
KICKAPP handles check-ins, subs, teams and match fees for your game, and it’s free on iPhone and Android.
On a computer? Scan with your phone camera to get the app.
More guides
- How to organise a 5-a-side game
- How to collect football match fees
- Running a youth football team
- How many players for 5-a-side, 6-a-side and 7-a-side?
- KICKAPP vs WhatsApp for organising football
- How to find players for your 5-a-side game
- Where to play 5-a-side in winter
- How to find a 5-a-side team to join
- Starting a Sunday league team